Play It Again Sports Near Me: Find Locations, Hours & Gear

You’ve got an old hockey stick, a dusty treadmill, or maybe a set of golf clubs that barely saw a fairway – and the idea of getting cash for them and picking up a replacement without paying retail is appealing. Play It Again Sports has built a whole franchise model around that swap, and this guide walks through what to expect, how to find a store, and how to get the best deal on both sides of the counter.

Founded: 1983 ·
Parent Company: Winmark Corporation ·
Store Network: Franchise-based, independently owned ·
Specialty: Buy, sell, and trade used and new sports & fitness equipment ·
Online Shopping: Available at playitagainsports.com

Key data about Play It Again Sports at a glance:

Where Can I Find Used Sports Equipment Near Me?

Play It Again Sports stores stock everything from hockey skates and baseball gloves to treadmills and weight sets. The company tells customers that local stores provide an easy way to sell quality used sports and fitness gear and get paid on the spot, or trade up for what they need now.

Types of Equipment Available

• Team sports: Hockey sticks, shoulder pads, soccer cleats, baseball bats, football helmets
• Golf: Clubs from Taylormade, Titleist, Ping, Callaway, Scotty Cameron (Play It Again Sports)
• Fitness: Weight machines, dumbbells, yoga mats, treadmills, ellipticals
• Winter & outdoor: Skis, snowboards, skate sharpening services (Wikipedia)
• Accessories: Helmets, pads, bags, balls, nets

Condition and Quality Standards

Every piece of used equipment is inspected before it hits the sales floor. The company says it offers both new and high-quality used equipment, meaning items with significant wear or damage are either discounted heavily or not accepted. A Yelp reviewer of a franchise on Sawmill Rd, Dublin, OH noted: As far as used sports equipment goes, Play It Again Sports is usually pretty awesome in getting what you need.

Pricing on Used Gear

Play It Again Sports does not publicly disclose its pricing formula. Prices are determined at the store level based on brand, condition, and local demand. The implication: the final price on a used set of golf clubs in Greensboro may differ from the same set in Orlando, because each franchise is independently owned and operated.

The implication: local variation means shoppers should check multiple stores for the best deal.

What Are the Play It Again Sports Locations Near Me?

Finding a store starts with the official locator. Play It Again Sports directs customers to playitagainsports.com/locations to find the nearest store, where each franchise is independently owned and operated, so nearby store policies and inventory can vary by location.

Finding a Store Using the Official Locator

The locator tool shows address, phone number, hours, and a map for each franchise. Enter your ZIP code or city and state, and the site returns stores ranked by distance. Locations exist across the US including Greensboro, Durham, Winston-Salem, and Orlando (Play It Again Sports).

Examples: Greensboro, Durham, Winston-Salem, Orlando

• Greensboro, NC — Multiple franchises in the Piedmont Triad region; inventory typically includes baseball, golf, and fitness gear
• Durham, NC — Serves Triangle-area customers; college sports equipment is common
• Winston-Salem, NC — A single franchise location with standard hours
• Orlando, FL — At least two locations; fitness and golf equipment are top sellers

Franchise Independence and Local Operations

Each franchise is independently owned and operated (Play It Again Sports). This means local owners set their own hours, pricing, and acceptance policies. Winmark Corporation — the parent company that also runs Once Upon A Child, Music Go Round, Plato’s Closet, and Style Encore — provides the brand framework, but day-to-day decisions rest with the local franchisee.

The pattern: the same brand and logo, but the experience — from friendliness to selection to checkout speed — can vary from one street to the next. For buyers, that means visiting a second location is worth the drive if the first one felt weak.

Is Play It Again Sports Open Now? (Hours and Availability)

Store hours are not uniform. Because each franchise is independently owned, operating hours are set at the local level, and the official site provides hours for each store. Checking a specific location before heading out is essential.

Typical Store Hours

Most Play It Again Sports franchises follow a standard retail schedule: Monday through Saturday from 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM or 9:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 6:00 PM. However, the official store locator lists exact hours for every franchise.

Checking Hours for a Specific Location

Enter your ZIP code or city on playitagainsports.com/locations and click on the store listing. The hours appear in the popup card. Most locations also have a phone number you can call for same-day confirmation.

Holiday and Seasonal Variations

Some stores may have extended hours during peak seasons such as back-to-school (August–September) and pre-holiday (November–December) when demand for used sports gear spikes. Conversely, holiday closures on Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year’s Day are standard. A quick phone call before a holiday visit is cheap insurance against a locked door.

The pattern: official site and phone call provide the most reliable hours, not third-party listings.

How to Check Play It Again Sports Inventory Online?

Online shopping is available at playitagainsports.com. Items can be shipped to your home or picked up in-store.

Browsing Online Catalog

The online catalog lets shoppers browse by category — golf, fitness, hockey, baseball, softball, soccer, and more. Each listing includes the item’s condition (New, Used — Good, Used — Fair), price, and available sizes or specs. Inventory is updated regularly online.

Filtering by Sport and Equipment Type

Filters include sport category, price range, condition, and brand. If you want a Taylormade driver for under $150, the tool narrows the field in seconds. A shopper can also search by specific product name or SKU.

In-Store vs. Online Availability

Items available for online ordering may not reflect in-store inventory at a specific franchise because each store manages its own stock. The site clearly marks whether an item is eligible for ship-to-home, in-store pickup, or both. For shoppers set on a particular piece of gear, the recommendation is to reserve it online — many franchises hold reserved items for 24 to 48 hours.

The implication: browsing online is a great starting point, but the physical store remains the real treasure hunt. The best deals — especially on high-ticket items like hockey goalie pads or sets of irons — are often sitting on a shelf, not listed on the web.

How to Sell Used Sports Equipment to Play It Again Sports?

Play It Again Sports buys used sports and fitness equipment — and the process is simpler than listing items on craigslist or Facebook Marketplace. Equipment must be in good, sellable condition.

Items Accepted for Purchase

Most franchises accept the same categories they sell: team sports gear, golf clubs, fitness equipment, skis and snowboards, and sporting accessories. Items not typically accepted: helmets older than five years, damaged or heavily worn goods, apparel that is not in excellent condition, and safety-sensitive equipment (like climbing ropes or carabiners).

Condition Requirements

The equipment must be clean and functional. A bike with rusted chain links, a hockey stick with a cracked shaft, or a treadmill with a broken belt will likely be refused. Play It Again Sports says it accepts quality used sports and fitness gear — meaning items that are safe, clean, and ready for resale with minimal refurbishment.

Pricing and Payment Process

Payment is made at the store at the time of sale. The store manager or associate evaluates each item against current demand and inventory levels and makes a cash offer. There is no appointment needed for most locations — simply walk in during store hours with clean, functional gear. The company’s official site describes the process as easy to sell quality used sports and fitness gear and get paid on the spot.

1. Gather clean, functional sports equipment in good sellable condition.
2. Visit any Play It Again Sports franchise location during operating hours — no appointment needed.
3. Present items to a store associate for evaluation based on brand, condition, and local demand.
4. Receive a cash offer on the spot or choose store credit for a slightly higher value if available.
5. Accept the offer and get paid immediately, or decline and take your items back.

The catch: while the offer is lower than peer-to-peer sales, the speed and convenience are often worth the trade-off.

“Play It Again Sports buys and sells quality used and new sports and fitness equipment.”

— Play It Again Sports official site (Play It Again Sports)

“As far as used sports equipment goes, Play It Again Sports is usually pretty awesome in getting what you need.”

— Yelp reviewer, Sawmill Rd, Dublin, OH (Yelp)

If you’re curious about what Play It Again Sports buys and how the franchise works, what Play It Again Sports buys provides a detailed breakdown of their policies and inventory.

Frequently Asked Questions